What is Cross-Talk Compensation in Controls?

July 31, 2015

Provided by Julian Renz, HEIDENHAIN Product Specialist, Machine Tools

Figure 1: Stud on square, milled with CTC; no visible flat spot

Figure 1: Stud on square, milled with CTC; no visible flat spot

Compensation of acceleration-dependent position errors at the tool center point leads to better machining results                       

When feed axes are accelerated, machine components can be deformed or begin to oscillate because of inertia forces. For example, if the spindle head of a gantry-style machine is accelerated in y-direction and then decelerates to stop at the designated position, the machine components in motion (i.e. the spindle and its components) tend to overshoot in the same direction (y-direction). This leads to deviations at the Tool Center Point (TCP), which can lead to inaccurate workpieces.

However, if the feed forces are not in line with the center of gravity of the y-axis, mechanical coupling causes the axes perpendicular to the y-axis to oscillate as well (x- and z-axis). These pitching movements are called “cross talk” at HEIDENHAIN.

Figure 2: Effect of elastic deflection (the overlarge stud is flattened when the square is milled)

Figure 2: Effect of elastic deflection (the overlarge stud is flattened when the square is milled)

A control feature called Cross-Talk Compensation (CTC) can significantly reduce deviations at the TCP for the primary oscillations in feed force-direction and for the pitching movements. CTC allows achieving a high surface finish without the need to slow down the feed

rate in order to stay within tolerance. Only HEIDENHAIN offers this CTC function.

 Milling of a rectangular stud after a circular stud on top was milled first

Figure 3: Accuracy of the circular movement. The deviation from the nominal contour is shown enlarged 500-fold

Figure 3: Accuracy of the circular movement. The deviation from the nominal contour is shown enlarged 500-fold

As shown in Figure 1, CTC is active and the circular stud has no surface cuts. In contrast, Figure 2 (CTC inactive) shows that a little piece is cut off the circular stud.

An explanation for this is illustrated in Figure 3, which shows the tool path and deviations from it as measured with a cross grid encoder.

In the case with CTC active, the circular stud is machined more like an ellipse instead of the programmed circle. This is because the machine overshoots as acceleration values are changed. Thus, the protruding piece of the circular stud is cut off (as shown in Figure 2) as the cutter moves along the rectangular stud underneath.

Want to learn more?

Contact us today

Related resources and news

ACU-RITE’s New DRO Software Controls EDM Machines

SCHAUMBURG, IL (October 2019) – HEIDENHAIN CORPORATION’s ACU-RITE brand introduces new software for its versatile 300 Series digital readout (DRO) that now allows users to control a sinker EDM machine. This new development broadens this established DRO’s use to include all of the most common manual shop machines such as milling, turning, grinding and now […]

Read more »

Free 5-Axis Machining Workshops

One-day 5-axis machining workshops are now offered at various locations around the country and free to those who register. Co-hosted with HEIDENHAIN and other machining companies, attendees will learn how to take advantage of the latest developments in manufacturing by experts in the field and receive a free lunch to boot! At each of these […]

Read more »

Bearing the Load of Complex Motion Control

Developing new products often forces manufacturers of highly accurate machines to push the envelope of the technologically possible. At this juncture, HEIDENHAIN provides support for robust systems with new motion control solutions perfectly tailored to the requirements of many different applications and industries. The more demanding the application, the simpler the solution can be. This […]

Read more »